|
|
What are lighting environmental zones?
Although the goal may be to eliminate light pollution, in some locations light pollution cannot be avoided altogether. The environmental consequences of the pollution, however, need not be equally detrimental across all locations. The Commission Internationale de l’Eclairage (CIE) has outlined four environmental zones to establish a basis for outdoor lighting regulations (CIE 1997). The environmental zone rating can be used to help ensure that the lighting goals of an environment are appropriately defined and met, but not exceeded. The Illuminating Engineering Society of North America (IESNA) has adopted the concept of environmental zones (described in Table 1) and recommends their use in developing new outdoor lighting (IESNA 1999). In some states legislation is being considered that would restrict outdoor lighting by environmental zone. For example, California has drafted environmental legislation that includes the designation of outdoor lighting zones (CEC 2002). Application of environmental zones is first envisioned for the protection of natural park preserves and astronomical observatories. Environmental zones promise to reduce overall light pollution by helping to limit, or in some cases eliminate, light wastage.
| Table 1. Description of the lighting environmental zones, as adapted by IESNA |
|
| Zone rating |
Description |
|
| E1 |
Areas with intrinsically dark landscapes
National parks or residential areas with strict limits on light trespass
Roads usually unlit |
|
| E2 |
Areas of low ambient brightness
Outer urban or rural residential areas |
|
| E3 |
Areas of medium ambient brightness
Urban residential areas |
|
| E4 |
Areas of high ambient brightness
Urban areas, residential and commercial with high levels of night time activity |
Source: IESNA 1999 |
|
The IESNA gives recommendations for pre-curfew and post-curfew light levels to limit light trespass (IESNA 1999). Pre-curfew is from dusk until 11:00 p.m. local time, when the area being illuminated is more likely to be in use. Post-curfew is from 11:00 p.m. to 7:00 a.m. local time. Recommended lighting levels are higher during pre-curfew time (IESNA 1999). The Institution of Lighting Engineers (ILE) provides guidelines on obtrusive light limits for sky glow, light trespass, and glare in exterior lighting installations (ILE 2000).
|