Lighting Research Center Lighting Research Center
    Volume 6 Issue 1
July 2002    
Does a T5 lamp give as much light as a T8 lamp?

T5 high output (T5 HO) lamps have greater luminous flux per unit length than standard T8 lamps, but the light output of standard T5 lamps per unit length is almost identical to the standard T8 lamps. If, however, this question requires a more precise answer and lamp efficacy needs to be taken into account, several factors affecting the light output-and therefore efficacy—should be considered.

One of the most significant factors affecting lamp light output is ambient temperature. Table 1-7 summarizes light outputs and efficacies of nominal four-foot standard T5, T5 HO, and standard T8 lamps. Manufacturers usually provide light output data at the optimal temperature for each lamp type in their catalogs: 35°C (95°F) for the standard T5 and T5 HO lamps and 25°C (77°F) for the T8 lamps. Light output data for T5 lamps at 25°C (77°F) and for T8 lamps at 35°C (95°F) are also available from manufacturers, however. Table 1-7 shows that, at 25°C (77°F), the light output of T8 lamps is higher than the standard T5 lamps. At 35°C (95°F), however, the standard T5's light output is higher than that of the T8 lamp. With respect to lamp efficacy, the standard T5 lamps are more efficacious than the standard T8 lamps at 35°C (95°F), but the two types of lamps are nearly identical at 25°C (77°F). The lamp efficacy of T5 HO lamps is higher than the T8 lamps but lower than the standard T5 lamps at 35°C (95°F), and it is the lowest at 25°C (77°F).

Ballast losses are another important factor. Table 1-7 compares lamp-ballast system efficacies for T5 and T8 systems from two ballast manufacturers. The data on lamp efficacy are quoted from manufacturers' catalogs (Philips Lighting 2001/2002; OSRAM SYLVANIA 2002). Although the lamp-ballast system efficacy varies among manufacturers, the maximum system efficacy at the optimal temperature for each of the three lamp-ballast systems (standard T5, T5 HO, and T8 systems) appears to be nearly identical on average.

Table 1-7. Lamp Efficacies and System Efficacies of T5, T5 HO, and T8 Lamps
(All lamps are nominally 4 feet. Lamp efficacy is calculated based on initial lamp lumens)

  Lamp Efficacy

  Lamp-Ballast System Efficacy

Manufacturer A**

  Manufacturer B**

Lamp Type Lamp Power Temperature Initial Light Output* Efficacy Input Power Ballast Factor Efficacy Input Power Ballast Factor Efficacy
  (W) (°C) (lm) (lm/W) (W)   (lm/W) (W)   (lm/W)

F28T5 28 25 2,610 93 63 0.90 75 62 1.00 84

35 2,900 104 63 0.90 83 62 1.00 94

F54T5HO 54 25 4,400 81 117 1.00 75 117 1.00 75

35 5,000 93 117 1.00 85 117 1.00 85

F32T8 32 25 2,950 92 59 0.88 88 59 0.90 90

35 2,714 85 59 0.88 81 59 0.90 83

© 2002 Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. All rights reserved. Next Next

Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
LRC Intranet Web mail Lighting Research Center