What are some important characteristics of metal halide lamps? (cont'd)
Color variation and color shift
Manufacturer A rates its 320 W pulse-start MH lamp at 3900 K and its 400 W probe-start MH lamp at 4000 K. Manufacturer B rates its 320 W pulse-start MH lamp at 4300 K and its 400 W probe-start MH lamp at 4000 K. Figure 9 shows that nearly all of the lamp chromaticities produced by both manufacturers lie outside the four-step MacAdam ellipse designated as cool by ANSI for linear fluorescent lamps. Although this four-step MacAdam ellipse is not strictly applicable to MH lamps, specifiers should be aware that fluorescent lamps and MH lamps of the same rated CCT may not necessarily have the same apparent color. There is also much greater color variation among the MH lamps produced by Manufacturer A than those produced by Manufacturer B, both at 100 h and at 40% of rated life. These variations are more clearly shown in Figure 10.
| Figure 10: Average color variations at 100 h of operation and at 40% of rated lamp life for 320 W and 400 W MH lamps from Manufacturers A and B |
 |
The paired histogram bars in Figure 10 represent the color variations in each of the four groups (320 W pulse-start and 400 W probe-start MH lamps from two manufacturers) of six, MH lamps. The average chromaticity coordinates of the six lamps in each sample for both testing periods (at 100 h and at 40% of rated life) are indicated below each histogram bar. The height of each histogram bar represents the average deviation of the six lamps in that group at both testing times (at 100 h and at 40% of rated lamp life) from their average chromaticity coordinates, measured in terms of "approximate MacAdam radii"; a four-step MacAdam ellipse has an approximate MacAdam radius of 4. Assuming that the four-step MacAdam ellipse represents a useful tolerance criterion in lamp color, it appears that nearly all of the lamps would have "acceptable" color variation at both 100 h and at 40% of rated lamp life.
The shift in color over time is another important criterion to consider with MH lamps. Figure 11 shows how far the colors shift from 100 h to 40% of lamp life for the four groups of high wattage MH lamps. The height of each histogram bar in Figure 11 represents the average distance in color space the chromaticities changed over the two test times for the six lamps in each group. Again assuming the four-step MacAdam ellipse represents a useful tolerance criterion for color shifts, all of the lamps from Manufacturer B shift by more than this criterion from 100 h to 40% of rated lamp life. Interestingly, despite the greater variability among the lamps produced by Manufacturer A at a given time (Figure 10), they tend to shift much less over time. Of note, the 400 W probe-start MH lamps produced by Manufacturer A are almost always within the four-step MacAdam ellipse criterion, between testing periods, as shown in Figure 11.
| Figure 11: Average color shifts for 320 W and 400 W MH lamps from Manufacturers A and B |
 |
|